Difference between revisions of "Instructional dimensions root"

From LearnLab
Jump to: navigation, search
(Explicitness)
(Does the tutor or the student do it?)
Line 32: Line 32:
 
(This dimension needs a better name) Should the tutor or the student do the steps in solving a problem?  Should the tutor or the student explain the steps of a problem’s solution?  In general, assistance is higher when the tutor does it than when the student does it.
 
(This dimension needs a better name) Should the tutor or the student do the steps in solving a problem?  Should the tutor or the student explain the steps of a problem’s solution?  In general, assistance is higher when the tutor does it than when the student does it.
 
* Adding example-studying to coached problem. ([[Stoichiometry_Study | McLaren, Koedinger & Yaron]];  [[Effect of adding simple worked examples to problem-solving in algebra learning (Anthony, Yang & Koedinger)| Anthony, Yang & Koedinger]];  [[Does learning from worked-out examples improve tutored problem solving? | Renkl, Aleven & Salden]])
 
* Adding example-studying to coached problem. ([[Stoichiometry_Study | McLaren, Koedinger & Yaron]];  [[Effect of adding simple worked examples to problem-solving in algebra learning (Anthony, Yang & Koedinger)| Anthony, Yang & Koedinger]];  [[Does learning from worked-out examples improve tutored problem solving? | Renkl, Aleven & Salden]])
* During coached problem solving, who detects the errors? ([[Intelligent_Writing_Tutor | Mitamura-Wylie]];  [[The self-correction of speech errors (McCormick, O’Neill & Siskin) | McCormick, O’Neill & Siskin]])
+
* During coached problem solving, who detects the errors? ([[Intelligent_Writing_Tutor | Mitamura & Wylie]];  [[The self-correction of speech errors (McCormick, O’Neill & Siskin) | McCormick, O’Neill & Siskin]])
 
* During coached problem solving, who decides when to ask for a hint? ([[The_Help_Tutor__Roll_Aleven_McLaren | Roll, Aleven & McLaren]];  [[Student_Uncertainty |  Forbes-Riley & Litman]])
 
* During coached problem solving, who decides when to ask for a hint? ([[The_Help_Tutor__Roll_Aleven_McLaren | Roll, Aleven & McLaren]];  [[Student_Uncertainty |  Forbes-Riley & Litman]])
 
* When studying examples, who produces or helps produce the explanations of steps? ([[Hausmann_Study| Hausmann & VanLehn]];  [[Craig_questions | Craig & Chi]]; [[Bridging_Principles_and_Examples_through_Analogy_and_Explanation | Nokes & VanLehn]])
 
* When studying examples, who produces or helps produce the explanations of steps? ([[Hausmann_Study| Hausmann & VanLehn]];  [[Craig_questions | Craig & Chi]]; [[Bridging_Principles_and_Examples_through_Analogy_and_Explanation | Nokes & VanLehn]])

Revision as of 13:52, 7 April 2007

Instructional dimensions being explored by PSLC projects

Existing PSLC experiments vary values along many instructional dimensions, so to simplify the exposition, the dimensions are grouped into 5 major classes and a 6th miscellaneous class. Each class of dimensions is listed below, with its dimensions beneath it. For each dimension, PSLC studies that compare values along that dimension are listed with it.

Peer collaboration

Problem solving, example studying and many other activities can be done alone, in pairs, or in pairs with various kinds of assistance, such as collaboration scripts. From the standpoint of an individual learner, having a partner offers more assistance than working alone, and having a partner plus other scaffolding offer even more assistance.

Repetition

In many kinds of instruction, similar or even identical tasks occur in sequence, with other tasks intervening. The more similar the tasks and the closer they are together, the easier they are for the student to achieve successfully during training, so the higher their they are in the assistance ordering.

Modality

Both the presentations and the responses from learners can written, spoken, diagramatic, gestural (e.g., menus), etc. Two modalities of presentation may in general be more assistive than one. However, the assistance scale for this design issue needs exploration.

Explicitness

Should the instruction present the knowledge to be learned explicitly (typically as text) or let the student infer it from multiple instance? Some of these dimensions do not (yet?) have a clear assistance ordering for their values.

Does the tutor or the student do it?

(This dimension needs a better name) Should the tutor or the student do the steps in solving a problem? Should the tutor or the student explain the steps of a problem’s solution? In general, assistance is higher when the tutor does it than when the student does it.

Miscellaneous

These are instructional dimensions from outside the categories listed above.